\newpage \subsubsection{Operational Semantics Rules Overview} \paragraph{Big-Step Semantics} \[ \begin{prooftree} \infer0[\textsc{Skip}$_{NS}$]{\langle \texttt{skip}, \sigma \rangle \rightarrow \sigma} \end{prooftree} \qquad \begin{prooftree} \infer0[\textsc{Ass}$_{NS}$]{\langle x := e, \sigma \rangle \rightarrow \sigma[x \mapsto \cA\llbracket e \rrbracket \sigma ]} \end{prooftree} \] \[ \begin{prooftree} \hypo{\langle s, \sigma \rangle \rightarrow \sigma'} \hypo{\langle s', \sigma' \rangle \rightarrow \sigma''} \infer2[\textsc{Seq}$_{NS}$]{\langle s;s', \sigma \rangle \rightarrow \sigma''} \end{prooftree} \] \[ \begin{prooftree} \hypo{\langle s, \sigma \rangle \rightarrow \sigma'} \infer1[\textsc{IfT}$_{NS}$]{\langle \texttt{if}\; b \; \texttt{then} \; s \; \texttt{else} \; s' \; \texttt{end}, \sigma \rangle \rightarrow \sigma'} \end{prooftree} \qquad \begin{prooftree} \hypo{\langle s, \sigma \rangle \rightarrow \sigma'} \infer1[\textsc{IfF}$_{NS}$]{\langle \texttt{if}\; b \; \texttt{then} \; s \; \texttt{else} \; s' \; \texttt{end}, \sigma \rangle \rightarrow \sigma'} \end{prooftree} \] \begin{align*} \begin{prooftree} \hypo{\langle s, \sigma \rangle \rightarrow \sigma'} \hypo{\langle \texttt{while} \; b \; \texttt{do} \; s \; \texttt{end}, \sigma' \rangle \rightarrow \sigma''} \infer2[\textsc{WhT}$_{NS}$]{\langle \texttt{while} \; b \; \texttt{do} \; s \; \texttt{end}, \sigma \rangle \rightarrow \sigma''} \end{prooftree} & & \begin{prooftree} \infer0[\textsc{WhF}$_{NS}$]{\langle \texttt{while} \; b \; \texttt{do} \; s \; \texttt{end}, \sigma \rangle \rightarrow \sigma} \end{prooftree} \\ \text{if } \cB\llbracket b \rrbracket \sigma = \texttt{tt} & & \text{if } \cB\llbracket b \rrbracket \sigma = \texttt{ff} \end{align*} \[ \begin{prooftree} \infer0[\textsc{Ass}$_{NS}$]{\langle x := e, \sigma \rangle \rightarrow \sigma[x \mapsto \cA\llbracket e \rrbracket \sigma]} \end{prooftree} \qquad \begin{prooftree} \infer0[\textsc{Ass}$_{NS}$]{\langle v := v + 1, \sigma_\text{zero} \rangle \rightarrow \sigma[v \mapsto \cA\llbracket v + 1 \rrbracket \sigma_\text{zero}]} \end{prooftree} \] \paragraph{Small-Step Semantics} \[ \begin{prooftree} \infer0[\textsc{Skip}$_{SOS}$]{\langle \texttt{skip}, \sigma \rangle \rightarrow_1 \sigma} \end{prooftree} \qquad \begin{prooftree} \infer0[\textsc{Ass}$_{SOS}$]{\langle x := e, \sigma \rangle \rightarrow_1 \sigma[x \mapsto \cA\llbracket e \rrbracket \sigma ]} \end{prooftree} \] \[ \begin{prooftree} \hypo{\langle s, \sigma \rangle \rightarrow_1 \sigma'} \infer1[\textsc{Seq1}$_{SOS}$]{\langle s;s', \sigma \rangle \rightarrow_1 \langle s', \sigma' \rangle} \end{prooftree} \qquad \begin{prooftree} \hypo{\langle s', \sigma' \rangle \rightarrow_1 \langle s'', \sigma' \rangle} \infer1[\textsc{Seq2}$_{SOS}$]{\langle s;s', \sigma \rangle \rightarrow_1 \langle s'';s', \sigma' \rangle} \end{prooftree} \] \[ \begin{prooftree} \infer0[\textsc{IfT}$_{SOS}$]{\langle \texttt{if}\; b \; \texttt{then} \; s \; \texttt{else} \; s' \; \texttt{end}, \sigma \rangle \rightarrow_1 \langle s', \sigma' \rangle} \end{prooftree} \qquad \begin{prooftree} \infer0[\textsc{IfF}$_{SOS}$]{\langle \texttt{if}\; b \; \texttt{then} \; s \; \texttt{else} \; s' \; \texttt{end}, \sigma \rangle \rightarrow_1 \langle s', \sigma' \rangle} \end{prooftree} \] \[ \begin{prooftree} \hypo{\langle s, \sigma \rangle \rightarrow_1 \sigma'} \infer1[\textsc{IfT1}$_{SOS}$]{\langle \texttt{if}\; b \; \texttt{then} \; s \; \texttt{else} \; s' \; \texttt{end}, \sigma \rangle \rightarrow_1 \sigma'} \end{prooftree} \qquad \begin{prooftree} \hypo{\langle s, \sigma \rangle \rightarrow_1 \langle s'', \sigma' \rangle} \infer1[\textsc{IfT2}$_{SOS}$]{\langle \texttt{if}\;b \; \texttt{then} \; s \; \texttt{else} \; s' \; \texttt{end}, \sigma \rangle \rightarrow_1 \langle s''', \sigma' \rangle} \end{prooftree} \] \[ \begin{prooftree} \infer0[\textsc{While}$_{SOS}$]{\langle \texttt{while} \; b \; \texttt{do} \; s \; \texttt{end}, \sigma \rangle \rightarrow_1 \langle \texttt{if} \; b \; \texttt{then} \; s; \; \texttt{while} \; b \; \texttt{do} \; s \; \texttt{end else skip end}, \sigma \rangle} \end{prooftree} \] \paragraph{Extensions} \subparagraph{Big-Step Semantics} \[ \begin{prooftree} \hypo{\langle s, \sigma[x \mapsto \cA \llbracket e \rrbracket \sigma] \rangle \rightarrow \sigma' } \infer1[\textsc{Loc}$_{NS}$]{\langle \texttt{var x := e in s end}, \sigma \rangle \rightarrow \sigma'[x \mapsto \sigma(x)]} \end{prooftree} \qquad \begin{prooftree} \hypo{\langle s, \sigma_\text{zero}[\overrightharpoon{x_i} \mapsto \overrightharpoon{\cA \llbracket e_i \rrbracket \sigma}] [\overrightharpoon{y_j} \mapsto \overrightharpoon{\sigma(z_j)}] \rangle \rightarrow \sigma'} \infer1[\textsc{Call}$_{NS}$]{\langle p(\overrightharpoon{e_i}; \overrightharpoon{z_j}), \sigma \rangle \rightarrow \sigma[\overrightharpoon{z_j} \mapsto \overrightharpoon{\sigma'(y_j)}]} \end{prooftree} \] \[ \begin{prooftree} \hypo{\langle s, \sigma \rangle \rightarrow \sigma'} \infer1[\textsc{ND1}$_{NS}$]{\langle s \bigbox s', \sigma \rangle \rightarrow \sigma'} \end{prooftree} \qquad \begin{prooftree} \hypo{\langle s', \sigma \rangle \rightarrow \sigma'} \infer1[\textsc{ND2}$_{NS}$]{\langle s \bigbox s', \sigma \rangle \rightarrow \sigma'} \end{prooftree} \] \subparagraph{Small-Step Semantics} \[ \begin{prooftree} \infer0[\textsc{Loc}$_{SOS}$]{\langle \texttt{var x:= e in s end}, \sigma \rangle \rightarrow_1 \langle \texttt{s;restore }(x, \sigma(x)), \sigma[x \mapsto \cA \llbracket e \rrbracket \sigma] \rangle} \end{prooftree} \] \[ \begin{prooftree} \infer0[\textsc{Ret}$_{SOS}$]{\langle \texttt{restore }(x, \sigma(x)), \sigma \rangle \rightarrow_1 \sigma[x \mapsto v]} \end{prooftree} \] \[ \begin{prooftree} \infer0[\textsc{ND1}$_{SOS}$]{\langle s \bigbox s', \sigma \rangle \rightarrow_1 \langle s, \sigma \rangle} \end{prooftree} \qquad \begin{prooftree} \infer0[\textsc{ND2}$_{SOS}$]{\langle s \bigbox s', \sigma \rangle \rightarrow_1 \langle s, \sigma' \rangle} \end{prooftree} \] \[ \begin{prooftree} \hypo{\langle s, \sigma \rangle \rightarrow_1 \langle s'', \sigma' \rangle} \infer1[\textsc{Par1}$_{SOS}$]{\langle s \texttt{ par } s', \sigma \rangle \rightarrow_1 \langle s'' \texttt{ par } s', \sigma' \rangle} \end{prooftree} \qquad \begin{prooftree} \hypo{\langle s, \sigma \rangle \rightarrow_1 \sigma'} \infer1[\textsc{Par2}$_{SOS}$]{\langle s \texttt{ par } s', \sigma \rangle \rightarrow_1 \langle s', \sigma' \rangle} \end{prooftree} \] \[ \begin{prooftree} \hypo{\langle s', \sigma \rangle \rightarrow_1 \langle s'', \sigma' \rangle} \infer1[\textsc{Par3}$_{SOS}$]{\langle s \texttt{ par } s', \sigma \rangle \rightarrow_1 \langle s \texttt{ par } s'', \sigma' \rangle} \end{prooftree} \qquad \begin{prooftree} \hypo{\langle s', \sigma \rangle \rightarrow_1 \sigma'} \infer1[\textsc{Par4}$_{SOS}$]{\langle s \texttt{ par } s', \sigma \rangle \rightarrow_1 \langle s, \sigma' \rangle} \end{prooftree} \]